The short answer
A Shopify CRO agency pinpoints where shoppers abandon your store, then runs controlled A/B tests on live traffic and keeps only the changes that lift revenue. Pick one that has shipped Shopify Plus projects, sets test length and sample size before launch, reports losing tests as openly as wins, and builds its own changes.
Say you run a Shopify Plus store doing $12 million a year. Ad spend keeps climbing, but sales stay flat. Honestly, the problem usually isn't your traffic. Visitors are leaving before they buy. A good Shopify CRO agency finds exactly where that happens and fixes it. Maybe you've already tried new ads or a new theme. The numbers still didn't move. This guide covers what these agencies do, how to pick one, and where to start. We also cover what to ask before you sign. Along the way, you'll see real examples from our own client work. This guide is for brands doing $10 million or more on Shopify Plus.
What a Shopify CRO agency does
A Shopify CRO agency finds where visitors leave your store without buying. Then it tests fixes on real traffic and keeps the changes that win. CRO stands for conversion rate optimization. It's the work of turning more visitors into paying customers without buying more traffic.
Where revenue leaks
Most leaks show up in the same places. The product page is often first. A shopper can't find sizing, shipping times, or reviews, so they leave. The cart comes next. Then checkout, where a long form or a surprise shipping fee can end the sale.
Mobile makes all of this worse. Most of your traffic probably shows up on a phone, and small screens hide problems fast. A button that works fine on a laptop can sit under a sticky banner on an iPhone. Shoppers rarely report these bugs. They just leave.
If your pages drag on phones, our speed optimization service is built for exactly that.
Terms explained
Agencies throw around a lot of acronyms. Here's what the main ones mean.
- Conversion rate: The share of visitors who buy. 100 visits and 2 orders means a 2% rate.
- Average order value (AOV): What a typical order is worth. If customers spend $60 on average, your AOV is $60.
- Revenue per visitor: Total revenue divided by total visitors. This one ties the other numbers together.
- A/B test: Half your visitors see version A and half see version B. Whichever one sells more wins.
- Statistical significance: A way to tell if a result is real or just luck. Most teams use 95% as the bar.
Want to lift order size? Our cart gamification service targets AOV directly.
Who needs a Shopify CRO agency at $10M+ revenue
Bigger brands face different problems than smaller shops do. More traffic helps with testing. Each test still needs enough visitors to show a reliable result. Small stores can wait weeks for one answer. Big stores can test faster, but their checkout and catalog are often more complex. A single product page might have dozens of variants, bundles, and regional prices. Each one can break a test in a quiet way.
Bigger brands also sell in more countries, currencies, and languages. One checkout change can touch every market at once. That's useful when it works, and costly when it doesn't.
Many $10M+ brands also run wholesale or B2B alongside retail. Those buyers need net terms, volume pricing, and company accounts. Each one adds a path that can break.
Here's the gap many founders miss. Some agencies focus on smaller brands, so bigger stores can get less hands-on attention. Ask who will actually work on your store before you sign.
Signs you're ready for a CRO agency
- Your traffic is steady, and you check your analytics every week.
- You've tried a few fixes, but the results came and went.
- Your store works fine, but your conversion rate has stayed flat for months.
- You know your margins well enough to say what a sale is worth.
Signs you should fix the basics first
Some stores need the basics before any testing makes sense.
- Your tracking is broken, so you can't trust the numbers. A tracking and analytics setup comes first.
- Pages load slowly, especially on mobile. Start with speed optimization.
- Your offer is hard to explain in one sentence. A free store audit can show where that confusion costs you sales.
Testing a broken store just shows you the same leaks again. Fix the foundation first, then start testing.
How to choose a Shopify CRO agency
Look for real Shopify Plus depth, a clear testing process, honest reporting, and a team that builds its own changes. Those four things separate a useful partner from a slide-deck vendor.
Shopify Plus experience
Plus stores have features that standard Shopify stores don't. Checkout customization is one. B2B company accounts and wholesale pricing are others. Ask which Plus projects the agency has shipped in the last year. Then ask what broke and how they fixed it. If you're still weighing platform options, see our Shopify Plus development work.
Ask about checkout customization, too. Custom checkout code needs careful testing before every change goes live.
Testing method
Ask how they choose what to test. A good agency starts with research, not guesses. They review session recordings, heatmaps, and customer feedback first. Then they rank test ideas by expected impact and effort. Finally, they set the rules for calling a winner before a test starts.
A test that runs for two days can look like a winner. Ask how long they'll run each test and how many orders they need before they call it.
Ask one more question: what happens when a test loses? Good teams treat losses as useful data. You can read more about our A/B testing service before you compare agencies.
Who builds the changes
Some agencies hand you a list of ideas and leave the building to your developers. Others build and test the changes themselves. Ask who writes the code, who runs QA, and who checks results after launch. A slow handoff can stall a test for weeks. We handle design, development, and CRO under one roof, which removes one handoff.
Reporting
Good reports show the losses too. If an agency only shares wins, treat that as a red flag. Ask for a sample report before you hire anyone. Look for revenue per visitor, conversion rate, and AOV. You also want the test length and sample size on every result. You should be able to see the raw numbers, not just a summary slide.
Questions to ask on the first call
Use these four questions on your first call. The answers tell you more than any pitch deck.
- How many Shopify Plus stores have you tested this year?
- What's the smallest traffic level where you'd still run a test?
- Who will manage my account day to day?
- What do you do when a test loses?
Best Shopify CRO agencies for $10M+ brands
Here's how we built this list. We looked at Shopify Plus experience, published testing methods, public results, and fit for $10M+ brands. We checked each agency against directory listings and public profiles. It's a judgment call, not a scientific ranking. Your team and your store will decide the right pick.
Ecomm Wizards
We're first on this list, and that's a reason to check us closely. We're a Shopify Plus agency with 150+ stores built and $400M+ in client revenue generated, according to our site. Our CRO work runs alongside design, development, and marketing. That means one team can handle the test and the rebuild. Our client results are further down, so you can check the work yourself.
Best for: Plus brands that need CRO plus a rebuild, checkout work, or B2B setup. See our Shopify Plus development services for the build side.
Not the best fit if: you only want a one-time theme tweak or a single app install.
Other agencies worth a look
Craftberry is a Shopify partner with more than ten years on the platform, according to a third-party listing. It's best for brands that want long platform experience. Watch for: review their current case studies and testing process before you shortlist them.
Convertibles is a testing-focused partner. It researches, designs, builds, and launches tests on Shopify stores, according to its directory listing. It's best for brands that want testing without a full rebuild. Watch for: you'll need another partner for major redesigns or development.
Blend Commerce operates across the UK and North America. It offers conversion audits, UX research, test design, and Shopify development. It's best for Plus brands that want audits and builds from one team. Watch for: ask for client references from brands your size.
We left out app companies, since they aren't agencies. We also left out a few agencies whose claims we couldn't confirm.
Case studies: what good proof looks like
Strong case studies show the starting numbers, what changed, how long the test ran, and what happened after. Anything less is a story, not proof. Look for these five things:
- Starting numbers, like conversion rate and AOV before the work.
- What changed, in plain words.
- How long the test or project ran.
- The result, including the tests that didn't win.
- What the team learned for next time.
Our client results
Both projects below paired a full rebuild with conversion testing, so we label them that way. Ask any agency to split those gains for you.
111SKIN is a skincare brand founded by a dermatologist. We audited the store, built a custom Shopify Plus theme, and added a skin finder quiz. Conversion rate rose 46%, from about 1.4% to 2.1%. Revenue grew 21% year over year.
Candy Kittens is a premium vegan sweets brand. We rebuilt its store around gifting, with a three-step gift finder and an easier way to run seasonal campaigns. Conversion rate nearly tripled, from 0.9% to 2.5%. Average order value rose from $23 to $30, and the gift finder now drives 28% of transactions.
Want to see more? Our case study library covers fashion, sports, B2B, and subscription brands.
How to use other agencies’ case studies as a benchmark
Some agencies publish test libraries or experiment write-ups. Use those as a comparison point, not as proof of what they'll do for you.
Shopify Plus CRO services
Our CRO work connects to specific store problems. Here's how each one maps to a fix.
- Checkout and cart: If people add to cart and leave, start with our Shopify CRO agency service and A/B testing.
- Product and collection pages: If shoppers can't find what they need, a UX and UI audit shows where the page loses them.
- Average order value: If customers buy one item and leave, try cart gamification.
- Mobile speed: If your store loads slowly on phones, see our speed optimization service.
- B2B and wholesale: If you sell wholesale too, see our B2B store setup.
- Tracking: If you can't trust your numbers, start with analytics and tracking setup.
Red flags to watch for
- They promise a specific lift with no baseline numbers.
- They can't show a sample test plan or report.
- They can't explain how they decide a test is a winner.
- They run tests on too little traffic to get reliable results.
- Changes go live without a QA step.
Watch for a pattern, not just one warning sign. One gap can be a busy week. Several gaps usually mean the process is weak. Any one of these deserves a follow-up question. Two or more is a good reason to keep looking.
How we run CRO for Shopify Plus brands
Every engagement follows five steps. You can join at any stage, but the order matters.
- Discover and strategy: We analyze your store, data, and goals. A store audit is one way in.
- Design and UX: We improve the store experience so buying feels easier.
- Development: We build clean, mobile-first pages and test every app and integration.
- Launch and QA: We test, refine, and launch with full QA.
- Growth and scale: We keep running CRO, email, paid ads, and retention. Email work often starts with a Klaviyo audit.
Each step ties back to revenue. Discovery finds the leaks. Then design and development close them. Launch and QA protect the sale. Growth work keeps the gains coming.
Every project gets a dedicated strategist, not a project manager. That person is your main contact from the first audit onward. After launch, maintenance and support keeps the store stable.
Conclusion and next steps
Choosing a Shopify CRO agency comes down to a few questions. Do they know Shopify Plus? Do they test with a clear method? Do they show losses as well as wins? Who builds the changes? Ask those four, and you'll filter out most weak options.
If you want a second opinion on your store, start with our free Shopify store audit. Or book a consultation and we'll walk through your numbers together. You can also contact our team with questions, or browse our case studies.
Last updated



