Ecomm Wizards

Shopify vs BigCommerce: Which Ecommerce Platform Is Better for Your Business?

Shopify vs BigCommerce compared across pricing, security, B2B, enterprise and switching. See where each wins and which platform fits your business model.

Published 12 min read

The short answer

Shopify is better for most DTC brands that want fast launches, a huge app store, Shop Pay, and native POS. BigCommerce suits large, complex catalogs, heavy B2B needs, or multiple storefronts. Both are secure, PCI DSS Level 1 platforms. BigCommerce raises your plan automatically as sales grow. Shopify charges fixed plan fees.

Introduction

The email lands on a Monday morning. Your BigCommerce store passed $30,000 in yearly sales, so your plan moves up a tier. Nothing about your store changed. Only the bill did.

Since June 2026, more BigCommerce merchants get that email, because the sales limits dropped. No wonder so many founders are searching Shopify vs BigCommerce right now.

Here’s the honest version: both are strong hosted platforms.

The better pick depends on your business model, your catalog, and your team. So we’ll compare Shopify and BigCommerce round by round. That covers current pricing, security, B2B, enterprise plans, and switching. Each round gets a winner, and we total the score at the end.

We’ve built 150+ Shopify stores and helped brands move from BigCommerce. So we’ll be upfront about where BigCommerce still wins.

Shopify vs BigCommerce at a Glance


Shopify

BigCommerce

Starting price

$39/month, or $29 billed yearly

$39/month, or $29 billed yearly

Sales limits per plan

None

$30K a year on Core, $100K on Growth

Fee with outside payment gateways

2% / 1% / 0.6%

2% / 1% / 0.6% (since June 2026)

App store

Much larger

Smaller, more features built in

B2B

Native on every plan

B2B Edition

Multiple storefronts

Expansion stores on Plus

Multi-Storefront

Headless

Hydrogen and Oxygen

Catalyst (Next.js)

In-person POS

Native Shopify POS

Third-party POS

SEO

Strong basics, fixed URL paths

Flexible URLs

Security

PCI DSS Level 1, SOC 2 Type II

PCI DSS Level 1, SOC 2 Type 2, several ISO certifications

Best fit

DTC brands and omnichannel sellers

B2B-first and complex-catalog businesses

Round 1: Shopify vs BigCommerce, the Core Difference

Both are hosted platforms, so neither makes you manage servers. The difference is in how they add features.

Shopify is an all-in-one platform with a giant app store. Core tools like Shop Pay, Shopify POS, and Shopify Markets are native. Extras usually come from apps.

BigCommerce calls itself “open SaaS.” More features come built into each plan, and its APIs are strong. Its parent company renamed itself Commerce.com in July 2025, but the platform is still called BigCommerce.

Day to day, that means Shopify stores install more apps. BigCommerce stores need fewer, but tweak more settings.

Round winner: Tie. It depends on whether you’d rather add apps or configure built-in tools.

Round 2: Shopify vs BigCommerce Pricing

The sticker prices now match almost exactly. The difference is what happens as you grow.

Shopify plans

Plan

Billed monthly

Billed yearly (per month)

Basic

$39

$29

Grow

$105

$79

Advanced

$399

$299

Shopify Plus

From $2,300

—

Check Shopify’s pricing page for current prices.

BigCommerce’s new plans

On June 1, 2026, BigCommerce renamed its plans and lowered the sales limits. Base prices for the first three plans stayed the same.

Old name

New name

Monthly

Yearly (per month)

Sales limit

Standard

Core

$39

$29

$30K a year (was $50K)

Plus

Growth

$105

$79

$100K a year (was $180K)

Pro

Scale

$399

$299

$33,333 a month, then 0.9% on sales above it

Enterprise

Performance

Custom

From $1,499

Custom

Automatic plan upgrades

“I got bumped to a pricier plan.” That’s how it happens on BigCommerce. When your trailing 12-month sales pass your plan’s limit, BigCommerce moves you up a tier automatically. Shopify has no sales limits on its plans.

Transaction fees on both platforms

Here’s a myth worth retiring. “BigCommerce has no transaction fees” stopped being fully true in June 2026. BigCommerce now charges an Open Payment Provider Fee on gateways outside its embedded list: 2% on Core, 1% on Growth, and 0.6% on Scale. Shopify charges the same rates on Basic, Grow, and Advanced when you skip Shopify Payments.

Worked examples

Yearly plan costs only, billed annually, before card processing and apps. Shopify stores usually spend more on apps.

Yearly sales

Shopify

BigCommerce

$50K

Basic: about $348

Growth (forced up from Core): about $948

$250K

Grow: about $948

Scale: about $3,588

$1M

Advanced: about $3,588

Scale plus 0.9% overage: about $8,000–$9,000

Round winner: Shopify. Fixed plan fees beat automatic upgrades for most growing stores.

Round 3: Compare Shopify and BigCommerce Features Side by Side

“Which one will my team actually enjoy using?” Let’s compare Shopify and BigCommerce on the features you’ll touch every day.

Feature

Shopify

BigCommerce

Admin and ease of use

Simpler for non-technical teams

More built-in controls, steeper learning curve

Themes

Online Store 2.0, built with Liquid

Stencil themes

Variants

Up to 2,048 per product, max 3 options

Strong for very large, complex catalogs

Apps

Much larger app store

Fewer apps, more features built in

Checkout

Shop Pay, one tap for returning buyers

Single-page checkout with Apple Pay, Google Pay, PayPal

Marketing basics

Abandoned cart recovery, discounts, Shopify Email

Abandoned cart recovery, discounts, built-in coupons

One thing changed recently. Shopify used to cap products at 100 variants. It now allows 2,048 for all merchants, though the three-option limit stays.

Shop Pay is the big checkout edge. Returning buyers pay in one tap, and that often lifts conversion on mobile.

Round winner: Shopify for most teams. BigCommerce wins for very complex catalogs.

Round 4: Shopify vs BigCommerce Security: What’s the Difference?

“Which one is safer for my customers’ data?” Good news first. Both platforms handle hosting, SSL, server security, DDoS protection, and PCI compliance for you. You never patch a server on either one.

Shopify is certified PCI DSS Level 1 compliant, the highest level for handling card data. It also publishes SOC 2 Type II and SOC 3 reports and runs a public bug bounty program. Store owners get fraud analysis on orders and two-step authentication for staff.

BigCommerce holds Level 1 PCI DSS attestations as both a merchant and a service provider. Its security program follows the NIST Cybersecurity Framework. It’s also certified against ISO/IEC 27001:2022, 27017, 27018, 27701, and 22301. BigCommerce first reached SOC 1 Type 2, SOC 2 Type 2, and SOC 3 compliance in 2022.

So what’s the real difference between Shopify security and BigCommerce security? Both meet the top payment security standard. BigCommerce lists more ISO certifications, which some enterprise procurement teams ask for. Shopify’s bigger app store means you’ll want to watch app permissions closely.

Your own responsibility starts at your login. Staff accounts, two-step login, and app access are on you. Running a headless store? Your separate front-end hosting is yours to secure too.

Quick security checklist for either platform

  • Turn on two-step authentication for every staff account.
  • Remove ex-staff the day they leave.
  • Review app permissions every quarter, and uninstall apps you don’t use.
  • Limit who can export customer data.

Round winner: Tie. BigCommerce has more ISO badges, but both are very secure.

Round 5: SEO and Speed

“Will switching platforms hurt my Google rankings?” Not by itself. Both platforms cover SEO basics well, with a few differences.

Shopify gives you a fast CDN, automatic sitemaps, and some robots.txt control through robots.txt.liquid. The catch is fixed URL paths like /products/ and /collections/.

BigCommerce offers more flexible URLs, built-in rich snippets, and automatic redirects when you change a product URL.

Honestly, content, speed, and site structure matter more than the platform. The same goes for AI search. Clean product data and clear FAQ content help either store show up in Google’s AI Overviews and ChatGPT answers. See our Shopify SEO and agentic commerce services.

Speed works the same way. Theme quality and app count drive real-world speed on both. “My site is slow on mobile” usually means too many scripts, not the wrong platform. Both platforms are hosted, so Black Friday and Cyber Monday traffic spikes are their problem, not yours. Our speed optimization work trims slow Shopify stores.

Round winner: BigCommerce, narrowly. Its URL flexibility gives SEO teams a little more control.

Round 6: B2B and Wholesale

“I keep hearing Shopify is easier, but is it good for B2B?” It’s a lot better than it used to be.

Shopify B2B now runs on every plan, with company profiles, catalogs, net payment terms, and quick order lists (Shopify). Shopify Plus adds catalogs assigned directly to specific companies.

BigCommerce B2B Edition goes deeper on B2B-only workflows. You get price lists, customer groups, quote requests, sales rep tools, and punchout for procurement systems.

The fit comes down to your model. B2B-first manufacturers and distributors often prefer BigCommerce. DTC brands adding wholesale usually find Shopify simpler. Learn about our Shopify B2B setup and ERP integrations.

Shopify B2B and DTC example: Everlast. Everlast needed one store for serious athletes, casual fitness buyers, and trade accounts. Ecomm Wizards delivered a Shopify Plus rebuild with a 152% higher conversion rate. Daniel Summerson, Managing Director of Everlast Gyms, said trade portal revenue beat their projections. See our case studies.

Round winner: BigCommerce for B2B-first businesses. Shopify wins for DTC brands adding wholesale.

Round 7: Multi-Store, Headless, and Selling Everywhere

Running several brands or regions? Shopify Markets handles multi-currency and local pricing in one store, and Shopify Plus adds expansion stores. BigCommerce Multi-Storefront runs several storefronts from one admin, which multi-brand companies like.

Going headless? Shopify offers Hydrogen, hosted on its Oxygen platform. BigCommerce offers Catalyst, built on Next.js, which you can host anywhere. See our headless Shopify work.

Selling in person is where Shopify pulls ahead. Shopify POS is native, while BigCommerce relies on third-party POS tools. Both connect to Instagram, TikTok, Amazon, eBay, Walmart, and Google Shopping feeds. For subscriptions, Shopify has Shopify Subscriptions or Recharge, while BigCommerce uses subscription apps. Check our Shopify POS setup if you sell in stores.

On AI, Shopify Magic and Sidekick come built into Shopify. BigCommerce is pushing hard on agentic commerce under its Commerce.com brand. Shopify also ships big updates twice a year through Shopify Editions.

Round winner: Shopify for omnichannel brands. BigCommerce wins for multi-brand storefronts and headless teams wanting hosting freedom.

Round 8: Which Is Better: Shopify Plus vs. BigCommerce?

For larger brands, the real matchup is Shopify Plus against BigCommerce Performance, the plan formerly called Enterprise.


Shopify Plus

BigCommerce Performance

Starting price

From $2,300 a month

From $1,499 a month, billed annually, custom terms

API limits

1,000 points per second, 10x standard plans

Higher limits, custom

Checkout

Deep checkout customization

Customizable checkout

Automation

Shopify Flow

Built-in workflows and apps

Multiple stores

Expansion stores

Multi-Storefront

B2B

Catalogs assigned directly to companies

B2B Edition

Sales-based upgrades

None

None on Performance

BigCommerce can look cheaper at first. But total cost also depends on gateway fees, apps, and how much developer time each setup needs. Shopify Plus drops the outside-gateway fee to 0.2%.

So, which is better: Shopify Plus vs. BigCommerce? High-volume DTC and omnichannel brands usually fit Shopify Plus. B2B-first businesses, huge catalogs, and multi-brand storefronts often fit BigCommerce. Explore our Shopify Plus development work.

Round winner: Shopify Plus for high-volume DTC. BigCommerce Performance for B2B-first enterprises.

The Final Scoreboard: Shopify vs BigCommerce

Round

Winner

1. Core difference

Tie

2. Pricing

Shopify

3. Features

Shopify (BigCommerce for complex catalogs)

4. Security

Tie

5. SEO and speed

BigCommerce, narrowly

6. B2B

Split: BigCommerce for B2B-first, Shopify for DTC plus wholesale

7. Multi-store and omnichannel

Shopify for omnichannel

8. Enterprise

Split: Shopify Plus for DTC, BigCommerce for B2B-first

Which should you choose?

Your business

Better fit

New or small DTC store

Shopify

Fast-growing DTC brand with frequent launches

Shopify

Selling in stores and online

Shopify (native POS)

Social-first brand on TikTok or Instagram

Shopify

DTC brand adding wholesale

Shopify

B2B-first manufacturer or distributor

BigCommerce

Very large or complex catalog

BigCommerce

Several independent brand storefronts

BigCommerce or Shopify Plus

Next.js headless team that wants hosting freedom

BigCommerce

Our verdict: for most brands focused on DTC growth, Shopify is the better choice. BigCommerce is the stronger option for B2B-first and complex-catalog businesses.

Switching From BigCommerce to Shopify

How do you know it’s time? Automatic upgrades keep raising your bill. You need an app that only exists on Shopify. You want native POS or Shop Pay. Or your team is tired of waiting on developers.

If that sounds like you, here’s how switching from BigCommerce to Shopify works:

  1. Audit your store. List products, customers, orders, and content pages.
  2. Set up Shopify and choose a theme.
  3. Move your data with a migration app or a migration service.
  4. Rebuild custom features with Shopify apps or Shopify Functions.
  5. Map 301 redirects for every product, category, and page URL.
  6. Plan customer password resets. BigCommerce doesn’t export passwords, so send a friendly login email at launch.
  7. Test checkout, tracking, and integrations before you go live.
  8. Launch outside your peak season, never the week before Black Friday.

From our migration projects: BigCommerce category URLs rarely match Shopify’s /collections/ format one-to-one. So we build the full redirect map before launch day, not after.

Want help with the move? See our BigCommerce to Shopify migration service.

Common Myths About Shopify and BigCommerce

  • “BigCommerce has no transaction fees.” Not anymore for outside gateways. Since June 2026, it charges 2%, 1%, or 0.6%.
  • “Shopify only allows 100 variants.” The limit is now 2,048 per product.
  • “Shopify B2B needs Plus.” Core B2B features run on every plan.
  • “BigCommerce is less secure.” Both hold PCI DSS Level 1.
  • “Shopify is bad for SEO.” It handles the basics well. Structure and content matter more.

DIY or Work With a Shopify Agency?

Do it yourself

Hire help

A small catalog and a simple store

Thousands of SKUs or complex variants

Little organic traffic to protect

Google drives a big share of sales

No B2B, POS, or ERP links

B2B pricing, POS, or an ERP to connect

Plenty of time before peak season

A tight deadline

How Ecomm Wizards helps

Ecomm Wizards is a Shopify Plus certified agency with 150+ stores built and 8+ years of experience. Every project gets a dedicated strategist, not just a project manager.

Our BigCommerce to Shopify migration service moves your products, customers, and orders. We plan the redirect map and protect your rankings. The launch happens with zero downtime, so customers never hit a dead store.

Need more than a move? B2B store setup, ERP integrations, and POS setup all sit under one roof. You won’t juggle five vendors who don’t talk to each other.

Book a free consultation or get a free store audit.

So, Which Platform Fits Your Business?

Here’s the short version. Shopify wins most rounds for DTC brands that want fixed pricing, Shop Pay, and native POS. BigCommerce still wins for B2B-first businesses, very complex catalogs, and multi-brand storefronts.

In the end, Shopify vs BigCommerce comes down to how you sell, not which logo looks better.

Want more comparisons? Read Shopify vs WooCommerce and our guide to Shopify ERP integration.

Last updated

Frequently Asked Questions About Shopify vs BigCommerce

Shopify is usually better for a small business. It’s easier to learn, launches fast, and has no sales limits on its plans. BigCommerce’s Core plan caps yearly sales at $30,000, so a growing small store gets moved to a pricier plan sooner than most owners expect.

Yes, in some cases. Since June 2026, BigCommerce charges an Open Payment Provider Fee when you use a gateway outside its embedded list. It’s 2% on Core, 1% on Growth, and 0.6% on Scale. Shopify charges the same rates when you skip Shopify Payments.

BigCommerce moves your store up to the next plan automatically. It checks your trailing 12-month sales. Pass $30,000 on Core, and you move to Growth. Pass $100,000 on Growth, and you move to Scale. Scale adds a 0.9% charge on monthly sales above $33,333.

Shopify Plus is usually better for high-volume DTC and omnichannel brands. It offers deep checkout customization, Shopify Flow, expansion stores, and native POS. BigCommerce Performance often suits B2B-first businesses, very large catalogs, and multi-brand storefronts. Compare total cost, including apps and gateway fees, not just the plan price.

Both are very secure. Each holds PCI DSS Level 1 compliance and publishes SOC reports. BigCommerce also lists several ISO certifications, which some enterprise buyers require. On either platform, your biggest risks are weak staff logins and apps with too many permissions.

A small store can move in a few weeks. Larger catalogs with custom features, B2B pricing, or ERP links often take two to three months. Building the redirect map and testing checkout take longer than moving the data itself, so plan around your peak season.

Want this done on your store?

Book a free call. We'll look at your store and tell you what we'd fix first.

We've scaled 150+ stores. Let's see what's holding yours back.

Book a Free Call