Ecomm Wizards

Best SEO Agency for Ecommerce: How to Choose One and What to Pay

There’s no single best ecommerce SEO agency. Compare five agencies by platform, catalog size, and cost, plus the questions to ask before you sign.

Published 12 min read

The short answer

The best SEO agency for ecommerce is one that matches your platform, catalog size, and budget. Look for proven ecommerce case studies, a free crawl-based audit, ranked fixes with cost estimates, and a named specialist doing the work. Avoid guaranteed rankings. Shopify brands, Amazon sellers, and enterprise catalogs each need different partners.

Key takeaways

  • The best agency depends on your platform and catalog size.
  • Ask how much of your store Google crawls before you ask about keywords.
  • Filters and variants cause most of the slow traffic leak.
  • Check your platform's defaults, then check every app you've installed.
  • Get an audit before you commit to a monthly retainer.

Your traffic didn't crash. It slipped for months. Maybe you noticed when your monthly report turned into a wall of charts that explained nothing. That frustration is where most searches for an SEO agency for ecommerce begin. The honest answer is that there isn't one best agency for everyone. The right fit depends on your platform, how many products you sell, and what you can spend. This guide covers what a real ecommerce SEO partner does, how we ranked the agencies below, what each one costs, and the questions to ask before you sign.

Why ecommerce stores lose search traffic slowly

“Our rankings look fine, but nobody buys.” That's the sentence we hear most. Traffic rarely falls off a cliff. It leaks.

Google decides which of your pages deserve a place in its index. On a big store, that list gets messy fast. Filters create new URLs. Sorting options create more. Internal search pages get indexed, even though nobody needs them in Google.

The Pages report in Search Console shows this gap. SEO people call it index bloat. Put plainly, Google spends its time on pages that don't sell. Your best product and category pages get less attention, and organic traffic declines.

What an ecommerce SEO agency should actually do

A general SEO agency can write blog posts and build links. That's useful. But it won't fix a store with thousands of product URLs on its own.

Crawl and indexing for large catalogs

Start with crawl budget. Google only crawls so much of your site in a given window. You want that time spent on pages that sell.

Robots.txt tells crawlers where they shouldn't go. Canonical tags tell Google which version of a page is the main one. Faceted navigation, the filter menu on a category page, is where most problems start. Server logs show what Googlebot actually visits, which is often different from what you assume.

Category and product page SEO

Category pages do most of the heavy lifting in ecommerce. Someone searching “men's running shoes under $100” wants a list, not one product. That's search intent, and it should shape the page.

A good agency writes category titles that match how shoppers search. It also fixes product titles that compete with each other. Product pages need their own descriptions, not the supplier's copy pasted across dozens of stores.

Structured data and rich results

Product schema tells Google your price, stock status, and reviews. Organization and Article schema help Google understand who you are and who wrote the post. Google Merchant Center handles your product feed, which matters for Google Shopping.

One note on FAQ markup. Google shows FAQ rich results only for certain types of sites. Think of FAQ markup as a way to help search engines read your page. It won't guarantee a special result.

Migration and replatform SEO

Platform moves are where traffic often disappears. The fix is URL mapping, where every old page gets a 301 redirect to its new home. Build that list from a crawl of pages that actually rank, not just your sitemap.

Capelli Sports moved off WordPress to Shopify and kept 95% of its search value. Their project also delivered a 24% conversion rate lift. John Hardy moved from Salesforce Commerce Cloud to Shopify Plus in under three months, and we cover that project in the results section below.

If you're moving from WooCommerce, our WooCommerce to Shopify migration service covers the redirect work in detail: https://ecommwizards.com/services/migration/woocommerce-to-shopify

Internal linking and AI search visibility

Internal links help shoppers and Google find your best pages. Link category pages to buying guides. Link guides back to the products they mention.

AI search tools like ChatGPT and Google's AI Overviews tend to pull answers from pages that answer one question clearly near the top. Some people call this answer-first content, AEO, or GEO. We can't promise your store will get cited. We can make your pages easier for people and machines to read.

How we ranked the agencies in this guide

Ranking agencies is a judgment call, so we'd rather show our work. First Page Sage publishes its own weights: notable clients 25%, reviews 35%, company size 20%, years in business 10%, and media references 10%. Those weights suit a general audience. For ecommerce, different things matter more.

Our criteria are ecommerce-specific work, the range of platforms each agency handles, client results you can verify, pricing clarity, and whether the agency will turn down a bad fit.

Disclosure: Ecomm Wizards is one of the agencies listed below, and this article is published by Ecomm Wizards. Read the shortlist with that in mind. If we can't verify a claim, we leave it out.

Best ecommerce SEO agencies to shortlist

Here's a quick comparison before the details.

Agency

Best for

Platforms named

Pricing shown

Watch for

Ecomm Wizards

Shopify and Shopify Plus stores that want SEO tied to design and conversion work

Shopify, Shopify Plus, plus audits on other platforms

Set per store after a free first look

No monthly retainer for a Magento store

Sequence Commerce

US and North American brands selling on Amazon and Shopify

Amazon, Shopify

Custom

Ask for case studies from stores like yours

Thrive Internet Marketing Agency

Brands that want SEO bundled with paid search, email, and web design

Not stated

Budget bands on the contact form

Ask for a written scope

First Page Sage

Content-led SEO and thought leadership

Not stated

Not stated

Ranks itself first on its own list

Uproer

Enterprise and high-growth brands that want senior people on the account

Not stated

$4,000 to $10,000+ per month, per its guide

Built for larger budgets

Ecomm Wizards

We're a good match for Shopify and Shopify Plus stores that want SEO connected to design and conversion work. We audit stores on other platforms too, including Adobe Commerce, WooCommerce, and BigCommerce.

We won't take a monthly retainer to maintain a Magento store. That isn't what we're good at, and our service page says so. Every engagement starts with a free look at your store. We price per store after that, so we don't publish figures here.

Our ecommerce SEO agency service page explains the process in more detail: https://ecommwizards.com/services/ecommerce-seo-agency

Sequence Commerce

Sequence Commerce works with US and North American brands that sell on both Amazon and Shopify. They bundle AI search work into the same contract, which helps if you want one partner across both channels. Pricing is custom. Ask for case studies from stores that look like yours before you decide.

Thrive Internet Marketing Agency

Thrive fits brands that want SEO bundled with paid search, email, and web design. Their pricing appears only as budget bands on the contact form. Ask for a written scope before you compare numbers. Bands can hide a lot of difference in what's included.

First Page Sage

First Page Sage focuses on content-led SEO and thought leadership. It ranks itself first on its own list. Keep that in mind when you read its ranking, and check its client work on your platform before you shortlist it.

Uproer

Uproer targets enterprise and high-growth ecommerce brands that want senior people on the account. Its guide cites a retainer of $4,000 to $10,000 or more per month. That's a serious budget, so it fits larger catalogs better than a new store.

Victorious and 180 Marketing also appear on Uproer's list. We haven't researched them yet, so they aren't included here.

What ecommerce SEO costs

Affordable ecommerce SEO is possible. The price depends on what you buy, though, and sources don't agree on the numbers.

Typical monthly ranges

Here's the spread. One agency guide puts SEO retainers at $2,500 to $25,000 or more a month. Another puts ecommerce SEO at $800 to $5,000 or more. A third puts standard online stores at $2,500 to $8,000.

Those numbers look wildly different, and the gap is real. Most of it comes from catalog size and scope. A 300-product store and a store with hundreds of thousands of URLs need different work.

What drives the price

Catalog size and filter combinations matter most. Your platform comes next. A migration adds technical work that a monthly retainer usually doesn't cover. Content volume changes the bill too, and so does AI search work if you want it included.

Affordable options that still work

Start with a paid audit. You get a clear list of fixes, ranked by impact and cost. Then you can run the fixes in house or hire someone for part of the list.

Scoped projects often beat open-ended retainers. A defined fix to your filter setup usually costs less than a year of vague monthly work.

Smaller stores should hear the honest version. One guide notes that merchants under roughly $500K in sales often get more from fixing the basics in house than from a monthly retainer. We agree. We'd rather say that than sell you something you don't need.

Costs outside the agency fee

The agency fee isn't the whole bill. Plan for developer hours, app fees, content writing, and tools like crawlers and rank trackers. A redirect project still needs a developer to implement the changes, even when the agency handles the URL mapping.

Ecomm Wizards prices per store after a free first look. A store with 200 products and a store with 20,000 need very different work, so one published number would mislead you.

What breaks first on each platform

Every platform fails in its own way. Here's where to look first.

Shopify

Shopify handles many basics for you. Default settings block some problem URLs, like internal search pages. Apps and theme code can add new ones, though, especially filter apps. Check your apps before you blame the platform.

Our Shopify SEO agency page covers how we handle these checks.

WooCommerce

Filter links and plugins create pages. Each new plugin can add crawlable URLs, and most owners don't notice until the index is full. Review your plugins after every install.

BigCommerce

Filter pages get crawled and indexed unless you add rules yourself. Plan for that during setup, not after traffic drops.

Adobe Commerce

Catalog and canonical settings exist, but teams often never switch them on. Ask your agency to confirm each setting in writing.

Custom builds

Check that Google sees what a shopper sees. Content that loads late, through JavaScript, can get missed.

Specialist, generalist, or freelancer: which fits your store

Match the provider to your catalog. A big store needs someone who has seen filters and variants break before. A small store may not need that depth yet.

Ecommerce SEO specialist agency

This fits best when your catalog has thousands of pages. Specialists know how filters, variants, and product feeds break together. That knowledge saves money because they spot the problem earlier.

Generalist SEO agency

A generalist works fine for a small site with few products. Ask whether they've worked on a store with filters. If they haven't, they'll learn on your budget.

Ecommerce SEO strategist or consultant

An independent strategist or consultant is good for diagnosis and planning. They can tell you what's broken and in what order. They usually do less of the fixing, so you'll need a developer and a writer.

Building in-house

In-house works when you already have a developer and a content writer who understand search. Hire a specialist for the first audit, then keep the ongoing work in house.

Questions to ask before you sign

Start with the two-question test. How much of my store does Google crawl? And how many pages does Google hold compared with the number of products I sell? If an agency can't answer both, it's working from keywords, not your store.

Then ask who will do the work and whether you can see a live store they manage. Ask if you can keep the audit if you don't hire them. Also ask how long the contract runs and who owns the content and data.

Red flags and green flags

Watch for these red flags:

  • Guaranteed rankings. Nobody controls Google.
  • No ecommerce case studies, only general marketing claims.
  • Pricing that changes every time you ask.
  • Link packages with no real access to your site.
  • No mention of your platform at all.

Look for these green flags:

  • A free crawl-based audit before any contract.
  • A named specialist who does the actual work.
  • Ranked fixes with cost estimates attached.
  • A clear statement of who they're not for.

Check your own store this week

You can learn a lot in an afternoon. Start with Search Console. Open the Pages report and search the indexed URLs for your filter terms, like “color” or “size.” If the count runs into the hundreds, that's a warning sign.

Next, run a site search for your search results path, such as site:yourstore.com/search. If Google holds those pages, they're probably diluting your store's signals.

Crawl your store and sort by product title. Duplicates jump out fast. Then check your crawl stats for URLs you don't recognize. Odd paths often point to an app or a theme setting.

What results look like in real stores

Results vary by store. The clients below approved their results and logos.

Capelli Sports

Capelli Sports moved from WordPress to Shopify and kept 95% of its search value. The project also delivered a 24% conversion rate lift. A move like this depends heavily on how clean the URL mapping is before launch.

A store with 20,000 indexed pages

This one is our own site. Google held roughly 20,000 pages from it, but only 86 were real pages worth ranking. One setting, left unchecked, caused the problem.

Clearing it took months, not weeks. We removed the junk pattern outright rather than redirecting it, because a redirect keeps the old address on Google's list. Within three months, the count was down to 1,818. Google has to recrawl and drop pages on its own schedule, so cleanup takes patience.

Evie Lou

Evie Lou grew organic revenue 47% after we cleaned up a catalog that was leaking shoppers. Its conversion rate rose 82%, and its average order value rose 31%. The results came in within the first 90 days.

John Hardy

John Hardy moved from Salesforce Commerce Cloud to Shopify Plus in under three months. The store went live before Black Friday and grew its conversion rate 71%. Timing like that takes planning, and it's a good reason to map URLs early.

Next step: get a free store audit

Not sure where your store stands? Start with a free audit. We crawl your store, show you how Google sees it, and list the fixes in order of impact. You'll see what's broken before you spend anything.

Learn what the audit covers on our free Shopify store audit page: https://ecommwizards.com/free-shopify-store-audit

Last updated

Frequently Asked Questions About Best SEO Agency for Ecommerce

There isn't one best agency for every store. The right fit depends on your platform, catalog size, and budget. Large catalogs often need a specialist who knows filters and variants. Smaller stores may do fine with a focused generalist. Start with free audits from two or three shortlisted agencies, then compare what each one finds.

Monthly ranges vary a lot. One agency guide lists $800 to $5,000 or more for ecommerce SEO. Another puts standard online stores at $2,500 to $8,000. Large catalogs and migrations push costs higher. Smaller stores can keep spending lower with scoped projects. Ask for a written scope and price before you commit.

An ecommerce SEO agency manages crawling, indexing, and duplicate pages across filters, variants, and product feeds. A regular agency often focuses on blog content and links. Ecommerce work also covers category and product pages, structured data, and platform-specific fixes. If an agency can't explain how it handles faceted navigation, it probably doesn't do much of this work.

Yes, for the right store. A paid audit or a scoped fix list costs far less than an open-ended retainer. Stores under roughly $500K in sales often get more from fixing the basics in house. Affordable only works if the work targets real problems, such as filter pages, broken redirects, or thin product descriptions.

Many stores see early movement within a few months. Full recovery can take longer. Technical cleanup, like removing indexed pages that shouldn't be there, takes time because Google recrawls on its own schedule. Category and content work often shows up over several months. A store with many duplicate pages usually needs more time.

It can, if the move isn't planned well. The biggest risk is missing redirects. Every old URL should point to its new home with a 301 redirect, and the mapping should come from a crawl of pages that rank. Capelli Sports kept 95% of its search value during its move to Shopify. Avoid launching right before your busiest sales period.

Faceted navigation is the filter menu on category pages, like size, color, and price. Each filter combination can create a new URL. Those URLs can produce thousands of near-duplicate pages that waste crawl budget. Google then spends time on pages that don't sell. The fix depends on your platform and how each filter gets used.

Choose a strategist or consultant if you need a diagnosis and a plan, and you have a team to carry it out. Choose an agency if you want the work done for you, especially on a large catalog or a migration. Many stores start with an audit and decide after seeing the findings. Whichever you choose, ask who will do the hands-on work.

Want this done on your store?

Book a free call. We'll look at your store and tell you what we'd fix first.

We've scaled 150+ stores. Let's see what's holding yours back.

Book a Free Call